Category: Stu’s Reviews

Genre: Novel

Grade: B

Notable People: Paul Doiron

Title: Bad Little Falls

Review: This is the second I’ve read in Doiron’s series about Game Warden Mike Bowditch in “Downeast” Maine. It takes place in the most remote part of Maine , up at the Canadian border. The setting is quite interesting and the story is a decent one, but I find his characters without much substance and the books only fairly written. If you want Game Warden stories, go for Wyoming and CJ Box. as an side, this book had the most typos of any novel I’ve ever read.

Genre: Novel

Grade: A-

Notable People: Paul Auster

Title: 4 3 2 1

Review: A very appropriate offering for my 300th (can you believe it) review. Two things override about is book: 1- Auster is one our finest living writers and has produced an amazing body of work (try “The Music of Change”) over the last 30 years and 2- this one is an undertaking. Not only is it almost 900 pages long, but is complicated, VERY complicated. The life story of Archie Ferguson is told in four takes; each chapter is divided up into four separate sections (1.1, 1.2, etc.) that chronicle Archie and his family’s very interesting life in in four totally different, though quite related ways. What I mean is it’s four alternative realities through the same time periods (chapter one with its four components are ages 1-5 for example). It starts during the late 40s and goes through extraordinary detail of the turbulence of the 60s (best narrative I’ve read about the nascent anti-war movement). Very good piece of work, amazing story, vivid characters, But, as I said, not by any means a light read….it has taken me a month..…well worth it. Thanks to David for turning me on to this.

Genre: Novel

Grade: A-

Notable People: CJ Box

Title: Off the Grid

Review: This is another great installment in Box’s Wyoming Fish and Game Warden (Joe Gunther) series. Amazing feel for place in all his books. If you like the mountain West, hard not to like these. The series has always had a very dark and mysterious sidekick character, Nate Romanowski, who gets top billing in this one, for the first time…..with great success. Nate was born to be leading man. The book is filled with drama, spies, terrorists, life or death in- the- desert scenes and ruminations on family and life well lived. And the Governor is character for the ages. Box is at the top of his game and one of the best writing in this genre. Hard to put down.

Genre: Novel

Grade: A-

Notable People: Ivan Doig

Title: Ride with me Mariah Montana

Review: This is the third in Doig’s Montana Trilogy, written in the 80s and 90s and focused on almost 100 years in the life of a Montana family. This one cones absolutely full circle in which Jick MacAskill is now in retirement age and engaged in celebrating the 100th anniversary of Montana’s’ statehood, by traveling all over the state (and I mean all over) with his eccentric daughter and her former husband as they cover the centennial for the newspaper through words and pictures. The book started so slow I thought about cashing in by page 25, but stuck with it..….for major reward. Slow, slow…..but beautiful. a love song to Montana and every nook and cranny of it. Doig is self-effacing to the max and writes with great fondness for his characters. I spent two weeks finishing this book an came to savor it’s slowness. Heed for it to end. and by the way, it’s a well written story that reaches back 50 years and ends up looking to the future.

Genre: Novel

Grade: A-

Notable People: James Lee Burke

Title: Heartwood

Review: Burke is 80 and still going strong- writing the long running and excellent Dave Robicheaux series as well as the two western series –set in Montana and Texas. This is the Texas series- featuring lawyer Billy Bob Holland, an aging former Texas Ranger, with a closet full of skeletons (one who speaks with him hourly), an oil rigging- country musician son, a tough- as- nails, take no prisoners lady private investigator…and a boatload of moral crisis. The protagonists in Burke’ s books never get off easy…..more like go to hell and back…..but they sure do try to do the right thing. As usual, this one is filled with odd and imaginative characters, and the pulls of wealth and lust…tinged with an underlying religious symbolism and one overloaded religious fanatic (who is quite likeable). These books are exceedingly well written, confident, have that same love of place that Burke has for the Louisiana Bayou….and spin a very good story. Burke is a master.

Genre: Novel

Grade: B/B+

Notable People: Linda Castillo

Title: Breaking Silence

Review: This is the third in Castillo’s Kate Burkholder series (and 3rd I’ve read and reviewed)- which centers on a lapsed Amish police chief who comes back (from the Sodom and Gomorrah of Columbus) to the fictional town of Painter’s Mill in the real Holmes County, Ohio- in the heart of Ohio Amish country. Kate is a very interesting and complex character, the books are quite engaging and Castillo writes well. If you’ve lived in Ohio and/or are familiar with the Amish culture- there is a lot here to like……and the same even if you haven’t/are not. That said, I found this one a bit too farfetched for my tastes. How many serial or quite multiple murders can there be in Holmes County? Despite that, I still think this is a find for serial readers of any stripe, and the culture she explores is quite interesting and thought provoking

Genre:  Novel       

Grade:  A-

Notable People:  Pete Hamill

Title:  The Guns of Heaven

Review: The late Pete Hamill was simply one of the great American writes of the 20^th century. I have been reading his catalog over the last five years and yet to not be bowled over. You have to like stories that invoke the grittier side of life in the very big city (NYC), which is his passion, the way it once was in Woody Allen’s films…..kind of like a love song written to the Apple. Like many of his books, the protagonist on this one, sounds and acts a lot like the real life Hamill, who was ,by all accounts, a hard drinking, adventurous tough guy. He danced with the stars for years as a beloved columnist (with Jimmy Breslin and Norman Mailer) for the NY Post and later the Daily News. Hamill is also a devoted Irishman, which plays a key role in his work- especially this one; set in early 80’s Belfast and New York- it’s about being Irish in the latter half of 20^th century, both in Ireland and in New York. The IRA of the time is very prominent, and acts of crazy violence are right around the corner. This is a book with a an awful lot to like: the protagonist is a macho but humble hero, the characters are flawed but vivid, the setting is lovingly depicted and the story is deceptively alluring. The book was short for my taste, but could be read in one rainy day or a day at the beach. Good, good stuff.

Genre:  Novel

Grade:  B+

Notable People:  Carl Hiassen

Title:  Native Tongue

Review:  Inept burglars, elderly gun toting radical environmentalists, sexually depraved dolphins, hermetic former governors living in the woods…..this is pure Hiassen….the man loves the Florida Keys and his wild yarns…pretty funny throughout with some kind for warped story to boot. I thought this one did not have the charisma of the previous ones I’ve read, but quite entertaining. I found it slow going, but improved as it went.